Another way out: Systems must change for society to transform
Power has to lie in the ability of people to seize control of the future and take direction into their own hands
Real journalists wrote and edited this (not AI). Independent, community-driven journalism survives because you back it. Donate to sustain Prism’s mission and the humans behind it.
“There is only one fundamental question which has to be decided. Is the election merely an unmistakable sign of a desire for ‘social progress,’ or a desire for social reconstruction?”– C.L.R. James
“To be radical is to grasp the root of the matter. But, for man, the root is man himself.”— Karl Marx
I’ve come to understand that part of what I dislike about elections is the same as what frustrates me when I watch U.S. television and film. The overabundance of tropes and reboots makes watching extremely difficult. It can be alienating sitting through something alongside a group of people who seem to be elated and entertained by the tragic predictability of it all. Sure, as time goes on, casts might be diversified, and roles may be updated to appease a modern-day audience, but the essence of the show ultimately remains the same. The actors, much like politicians, mimic the charisma of those who preceded them and performed a role the best. It captivates audiences.
But what’s more dangerous here are the real-life implications of the political stage where all of this plays out. Life-and-death matters become themes that may or may not translate to concrete changes. And, just like in a film, you can go outside after you’re moved by a message and do something about it, or you can allow the fact that you were entertained by the consciousness of a cast’s presentation to be more than enough. One central point here is that supporting a good performance about a real issue is never enough.
I wasn’t sure what to write as I watched the U.S. midterm election results roll in. I had anticipated significant losses for the Republican Party, but the electoral consequences of Trumpism even exceeded what I imagined would happen. Knowing that millions of people cared enough about their futures—and that of those around them—to try to do something is not insignificant. It’s actually a beautiful insight to consider the potential that this kind of collective energy has.
At the same time, the jubilant reactions of many reminded me of November of 2020, when former President Joe Biden was elected. It reminded me of the relief that people felt that ultimately became a drug.
I watched people I cared about change for the worse and excuse the genocide of Palestinians just because it was being carried out by an administration they supported as a rebuke of President Donald Trump. After the unrelenting fire of the George Floyd protests, people had felt a release of rage and saw the “practical” alternative of voting as a release valve. The political establishment seemed to breathe a sigh of relief, knowing that the representatives they controlled had dominant influence over the landscape yet again, rather than the raucousness of unquelled uprisings. The pain and anger we feel about our conditions are open wounds. These wounds can be healed in different ways, and elections become anesthesia. They often numb us to the pain we would otherwise confront much differently if we didn’t have this outlet. And, like how anesthesia wears off, so too will the intoxication of representative democracy.
It’s all cyclical. After writing about it consistently for over 10 years of my life, I understand why some people grow tired and throw up their hands. Fascism cannot be overcome at the ballot box, and other countries that have seen some of the worst it has to offer tell us that pragmatic governance will not defeat it either. Opposition has to overturn that which dictates and enforces what we oppose. Yet liberalism is constantly convincing people that we have to negotiate with the established violations of fascism. This is why in recent years, the Democratic Party has become even more anti-immigrant, pro-police, and warmongering than times past. So, as the pendulum swings back and forth, the liberal base finds themselves in interesting positions cheering on the very people who support policies they claim (or claimed) to oppose.
The saddest thing I’ve learned during this era is how some people become infected with fascism during the fights against it.
The problem with the repetition of it all is the lack of evolution in the politics around us. People want huge, revolutionary changes from a location that may or may not offer them piecemeal reforms. By exporting decisions to a representative, the public regularly disempowers itself further while mistakenly believing this way of voting is the pinnacle of empowerment. Direct democracy, as opposed to representative democracy, is completely foreign as a concept. Asking someone to ask for changes on your behalf, however, is not. The systems we live under hope to keep this arrangement in place. That’s why undemocratic institutions like the Electoral College, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), and the Supreme Court must be abolished. These issues have to be pressed in order to increase the power of the public instead of comfortably trusting politicians to do right by their supporters. People will have to elect themselves and vote for confidence in their ability to discern and make the biggest changes we’d hope to see in our lives. If voters and non-voters alike are not seeking to increase public power, then change will happen in the negative at the public’s expense.
Another important element to understand about the situation in the U.S. is that fascists do not just retreat and take losses in a civil way. As we all learned and saw previewed during the January 6 U.S. Capitol attacks, “no” is not an acceptable answer. And for people who believe violence is not only acceptable, but preferable, their reaction cannot be underestimated. Gloating and celebrating too soon might miss the fact that the right-wing often plans far ahead and will stop at nothing to get exactly what they want.
Generations ago, in a situation with some striking similarities, C.L.R. James warned people after the 1945 United Kingdom general election that everything wasn’t necessarily as good as it seemed. The Labor Party won its first outright majority in a landslide victory, but years before there had been some accusations from the right-wing that this would mean some radical red revolutionary change. James describes the scene:
In the election of 1923 the British people gave to the Labor Party the greatest number of seats among the three contending parties. The Liberal Party and the Conservatives together held a majority over the Labor Party, which, however, formed a government with their consent. This government introduced not one single socialist measure. It had preached socialism for twenty-three years. In the campaign the Tories, then as now, had made it clear to the British people that as far as they, the property owners, were concerned, the Labor Party was a socialist party. Victory for the Labor Party, the Tories explained to the British electors, meant the substitution of a socialist society for a capitalist society in Britain. They called the labor leaders red revolutionaries, which, of course, the labor: leaders vigorously denied. Their denial was not without some justification. The British people, or the masses who support the Labor Party, were and are not Marxists.
Many decades later, this parallels the environment in which the fascistic U.S. right-wing accuses Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) aligned politicians of holding positions much more revolutionary than they actually do. This is possible in the U.S. because much of the population, including some self-identified socialists, has no idea what socialism is historically or currently. For the latter, it means something to the tune of roads, emergency services, and public schools administered through an entitlement-friendly nation-state. For the former, it means death camps, rations, and disastrous mismanagement of resources. In reality, just the word is enough to distort things in the U.S. because what we’re seeing based on the 2026 midterms is a rising number of social democrats among progressive liberals and traditional establishment corporate Democrats.
James warned in 1945 Britain that the abolition of capitalist property relations and revolutionary change were not the guaranteed results of such an election victory, even if people might have felt significant hope as a result. The same is true in the U.S. in 2026. As East German communist dissident Rudolf Bahro reminds us in his critique of “actually existing socialism,” in order to achieve something genuine there has to be a break. In his words, “Socialism as it actually exists, irrespective of its many achievements, is characterized by: the persistence of wage-labour, commodity production and money; the rationalization of the traditional division of labour.” Many countries around the world have already been through the ups and downs of socialist experiments while the U.S. still struggles with the basic definition.
Socialist labels, diversity, and progressive sloganeering cannot be the height of satisfaction for voters. Even fascists and their supporters are increasingly diverse in appearance—think Marco Rubio, Kash Patel, Nicki Minaj, Vivek Ramaswamy, etc. We have to differentiate between momentum and power. Power has to lie in the ability of people to seize control of the future and take direction into their own hands. It cannot be a cycle of constantly handing it off to representatives walking into a corrupted system while their voters hope for the best.
As I write this, Governor Keisha Lance Bottoms has selected billionaire entertainment mogul Tyler Perry for her transition team, and people are cheering because her name is Keisha. This is not systemic transformation. This cosmetic shallowness is part of the problem in a country plagued with political entertainers like the reality TV star president. If the systems don’t change, not much else will. Don’t mistake momentum for complete victory, and don’t underestimate the persistence of fascism.
William C. Anderson